The Ultimate Decadent Butterscotch Milkshake Recipe with Easy Homemade Sauce

Prepare for a truly indulgent experience with this incredibly thick and creamy butterscotch ice cream milkshake. This recipe stands out by featuring a luscious homemade butterscotch sauce, generously blended into the milkshake and artfully drizzled on top for an extra touch of decadence. Designed to make two generous servings, you might just find yourself wanting to keep both to yourself once you taste this exquisite frozen treat!

*This post contains affiliate links — as an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Please see my disclosure for details*.

If you’re a fan of rich ice cream desserts, be sure to explore more of my delightful recipes. Check out my No Churn Oreo Ice Cream Recipe for a simple yet satisfying treat, my Peanut Buster Parfait Ice Cream Pie for a dessert with layers of flavor, or my Oatmeal Cookie Ice Cream for a comforting classic with a twist.

Why This Butterscotch Milkshake Recipe is a Must-Try

My biggest guilty pleasure, despite all the elaborate cakes and cookies I love to bake, is undeniably ice cream. I’ve ventured into making several no-churn ice cream recipes and even a truly delightful ice cream pie. Yet, sometimes, the sheer simplicity of a classic carton from the freezer section of the supermarket is all you truly need to satisfy a craving. However, the experience can always be elevated!

In fact, the only thing that can truly transform classic vanilla ice cream into something extraordinary are some truly perfect toppings – and that’s precisely what we’re achieving today with this spectacular butterscotch milkshake! The flavors of butterscotch and vanilla are a match made in heaven, harmonizing beautifully. It simply makes perfect sense to amplify a traditional vanilla milkshake by infusing it with our own rich, silky homemade butterscotch syrup. This isn’t just a milkshake; it’s a gourmet experience in a glass!

What is the Best Milkshake Flavor? Unveiling a Butterscotch Favorite

I firmly believe that the absolute best milkshake is the one currently in your hand, being savored sip by glorious sip. And for me, this incredibly rich and creamy butterscotch milkshake ranks exceptionally high on that list! You might have your own personal favorite, but before you make a final decision, I urge you to indulge in a few sips of this super easy-to-make frozen treat. Its deep, caramelized notes and smooth texture are sure to win you over. Come back to me after tasting, and you might just agree that butterscotch reigns supreme!

Understanding Butterscotch Sauce: The Secret to its Rich Flavor

If you’re new to the wonderful world of butterscotch sauce, you might not realize that it’s quite similar to caramel, but with a crucial difference: it’s made primarily with brown sugar instead of granulated white sugar. This simple swap provides a much deeper, richer flavor profile, often accompanied by subtle notes of molasses that brown sugar naturally offers. When combined with a touch of vanilla and a pinch of sea salt, the result is an incredibly complex and satisfying sweet-salty balance.

Beyond its incredible taste, I also find butterscotch sauce to be a little more forgiving and easier to make than traditional homemade caramel. With caramel, there’s often a significant concern about getting the sugar cooked to precisely the right stage without burning it. Butterscotch, thanks to the brown sugar, tends to be more stable during cooking. For this very reason, the homemade sauce for this butterscotch milkshake comes together so effortlessly, allowing you to achieve gourmet results with minimal stress!

Crafting Your Butterscotch Milkshake: Essential Ingredients

Every exceptional milkshake starts with high-quality ingredients. Here’s what you’ll need to create this amazing butterscotch delight, along with notes on why each component is crucial:

Unsalted Butter: This is the foundation that puts the “butter” in our butterscotch milkshake! While I often use salted butter in various baking projects, here we opt for unsalted. This allows us to control the overall saltiness of the sauce more precisely, ensuring a perfect sweet and savory balance later on.
Dark Brown Sugar: The star ingredient for our butterscotch sauce. The extra molasses content in dark brown sugar is vital, as it contributes an even deeper, more complex rich flavor and a beautiful, inviting color to our butterscotch creation. Make sure it’s packed firmly when measuring.
Heavy Cream: Absolutely essential for the luxurious body and texture of our sauce. Heavy cream ensures it becomes wonderfully velvety, smooth, and utterly decadent, creating that signature rich mouthfeel.
Vanilla Extract: The perfect aromatic complement, vanilla extract enhances and rounds out the deep brown sugar notes in this sauce. For the best flavor, I highly recommend using a high-quality pure vanilla extract. Or, if you’re feeling adventurous, check out my post on how to make vanilla extract at home with just two simple ingredients!
Sea Salt: A pinch of sea salt is critical! It masterfully complements these rich flavors and brilliantly offsets some of the inherent sweetness from the butterscotch, creating a more balanced and addictive taste.
Vanilla Ice Cream: The base of our milkshake. Your favorite brand of vanilla, classic vanilla bean, or even French vanilla ice cream will all perform wonderfully in this butterscotch milkshake. Don’t be afraid to experiment, though! For a unique twist, you could switch it up and try chocolate, chocolate chip, or even coffee ice cream as your base.
Milk: I personally used whole milk to ensure my milkshake achieved an extra-creamy, supremely rich consistency. However, you can certainly lighten it up a bit by opting for skim or low-fat milk if you prefer. I haven’t personally tried this milkshake with non-dairy milk alternatives, but if you do, please let me know how it turns out! I’d love to hear your experience!
Whipped Cream: This topping is entirely optional, but it comes highly, highly recommended! A generous, high mound of light and airy whipped cream will undoubtedly take your butterscotch milkshake from delicious to an absolutely unforgettable next-level treat.

Essential Equipment for Your Butterscotch Milkshake

Making this butterscotch milkshake is designed to be a quick and easy recipe. To streamline the process even further, I highly recommend using an immersion blender. Also widely known as a stick blender or a hand blender, this handy tool allows you to blend your milkshake directly in the serving glass or a deep bowl, eliminating the need to transfer everything into a traditional, larger blender. It’s just a bit quicker and minimizes cleanup, though you can absolutely achieve fantastic results with any standard blender you already own! Here are a few other essential tools you’ll need:

**Small Saucepan:** For preparing the homemade butterscotch sauce.
**Measuring Cups and Spoons:** For accurate ingredient measurements.
**Serving Glasses:** Tall, chilled glasses are perfect for presentation.

Tips for Achieving the Perfect Butterscotch Milkshake

To ensure your butterscotch milkshake turns out perfectly thick, creamy, and flavorful every time, keep these tips in mind:

Cool the Butterscotch Sauce: It’s crucial that your homemade butterscotch sauce is cooled to at least room temperature before blending it into the milkshake. Adding warm sauce will melt your ice cream too quickly, resulting in a thin, watery milkshake.
Use Cold Ingredients: Ensure your milk and ice cream are very cold. Ice cream that’s slightly softened will blend easier but too soft will yield a thin shake.
Don’t Overblend: Blend just until the ingredients are combined and smooth. Over-blending incorporates too much air and can make the milkshake less thick and foamy. A few quick pulses are usually all it takes.
Adjust Thickness: If your milkshake is too thick, add a tiny splash more milk and blend again. If it’s too thin, add another scoop of ice cream.
Chill Your Glasses: For an extra-cold treat that stays enjoyable longer, place your serving glasses in the freezer for 10-15 minutes before pouring the milkshake.

Butterscotch Milkshake: Tips and Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between caramel and butterscotch?

The distinction is quite simple and comes down to the primary sugar used. Caramel is traditionally made with granulated white sugar, which provides its characteristic golden color and slightly toasted flavor. Butterscotch, on the other hand, is made with brown sugar, often dark brown sugar. This gives butterscotch a naturally deeper flavor with rich molasses undertones and a richer, darker color than caramel. Additionally, butterscotch recipes almost always include cream and vanilla to further round out its distinct flavors and creamy textures, making it a truly unique and beloved confectionery. The brown sugar also makes it a bit more stable when cooking.

Why is it called butterscotch?

The “butter” part of the name is quite straightforward, referring to the butter that is a key ingredient in the sauce. However, the origins of the “scotch” part of the name are a bit more debated and unclear. Some culinary historians suggest it comes from the candy’s original manufacturing location in Scotland, linking it to Scottish heritage. Others propose that it derives from the word “scorch,” which refers to the process of cooking or scorching the brown sugar until it achieves its distinctive caramelized flavor and color. Both theories offer plausible explanations for this intriguing name.

What are some delicious variations and toppings I can add to this butterscotch milkshake?

This butterscotch milkshake is wonderfully versatile and lends itself beautifully to various customizations! I absolutely adore the idea of enhancing its texture and flavor by adding crumbled praline candy for a nutty crunch, a handful of butterscotch chips for an extra burst of butterscotch flavor, or crushed salted peanuts for a delightful salty-sweet contrast. But honestly, any topping you can imagine will likely be a delicious addition to this already fantastic base! Consider chocolate shavings, sprinkles, or even a drizzle of chocolate syrup.

And if you’re truly a devoted butterscotch lover, you absolutely must try my Butterscotch Chocolate Chip Cookies for another incredible butterscotch-infused treat!

More Irresistible Ice Cream Recipes You’ll Love

If you enjoyed this butterscotch milkshake, you’re in for a treat with these other ice cream and frozen dessert recipes:

No-Churn Key Lime Pie Ice Cream: A zesty, creamy, and refreshing no-churn ice cream that captures the essence of classic key lime pie.
No-Churn Strawberry Ice Cream: Sweet, fruity, and incredibly easy to make without an ice cream machine.
Strawberry Banana Sorbet: A light and refreshing dairy-free option, bursting with natural fruit flavors.
Peanut Buster Parfait Ice Cream Pie: A decadent pie inspired by the classic dessert, perfect for special occasions.

📖 Recipe

Butterscotch Milkshake Recipe – Easy with Homemade Butterscotch Sauce

5 from 12 votes

Print
Pin Recipe
Rate Recipe

Save Recipe
Saved!

Thick, creamy butterscotch milkshake with homemade butterscotch sauce blended in and drizzled on top! The best butterscotch shake ever! Recipe makes two butterscotch milkshakes!

Prep Time:

5 minutes

Cook Time:

5 minutes

Total Time:

10 minutes

Course:
Dessert, Snack

Cuisine :
American

Servings:

2
milkshakes

Calories:

736
kcal

Recipe Source:
Chenée Lewis

Equipment you may need

hand blender
blender
measuring cups and spoons
small saucepan

Ingredients

4 tablespoon (56 g) unsalted butter
½ cup (110 g) dark brown sugar – packed
½ cup (119 g) heavy cream
¾ teaspoon (4 ml) pure vanilla extract
½ teaspoon (2 ml) sea salt
8 scoops vanilla ice cream – about 3 cups
⅓ cup (81 g) milk
whipped Cream – for topping (optional)

Cook Mode

Prevent your screen from going dark

Instructions

Add butter, brown sugar, and cream to a small saucepan and heat over medium heat.

4 tablespoon unsalted butter,
½ cup dark brown sugar,
½ cup heavy cream
Bring to a low boil and continue cooking, stirring occasionally, for about 5 minutes.
Remove from heat and stir in vanilla and salt. Set aside to cool — sauce will thicken as it cools.

¾ teaspoon pure vanilla extract,
½ teaspoon sea salt
To make the milkshakes, add milk, ice cream, and ½ cup of cooled butterscotch sauce to a blender. Blend just until smooth and immediately pour into two glasses to serve. If desired, top with whipped cream, more butterscotch sauce, and a tiny sprinkle of sea salt.

8 scoops vanilla ice cream,
⅓ cup milk,
whipped Cream

Last Step!

Click here to leave a review and a star rating! It helps spread the word and allows me to keep sharing free recipes! 🥰

Video

Notes

This butterscotch milkshake is endlessly customizable and perfect for tailoring to your preferences! You can opt for light vanilla ice cream and skim milk to save on calories if you’re watching your intake, or truly indulge with full-fat options for maximum creaminess. For adventurous palates, feel free to swap the vanilla ice cream for different flavors like rich chocolate, delightful chocolate chip, bold coffee, or even a nutty butter pecan. Furthermore, get creative with your toppings! You can elevate your milkshake with crushed candy, vibrant sprinkles, a swirl of extra butterscotch sauce, or any other fun addition that makes it a little more exciting and personal. Enjoy experimenting!

Nutrition

Nutrition Disclaimer

Did you try this recipe? Rate it below!

I can’t wait to see (and share) your results! Follow me on Instagram at @chenee_today and tag #cheneetoday!

Pin this butterscotch milkshake recipe for later and share the sweetness!