Ultimate Eggnog Bread Pudding: Brioche or Challah with Irresistible Brown Butter Rum Glaze

Prepare to be swept away by the most exquisite eggnog bread pudding you’ve ever tasted! This recipe transforms humble brioche or challah bread into a spectacularly rich and comforting dessert, perfect for any holiday celebration. Infused with the festive flavors of eggnog and a hint of warming rum, it’s all crowned with an absolutely irresistible brown butter rum glaze. If you’ve been searching for the ideal way to utilize that leftover holiday eggnog, look no further – this decadent bread pudding is a showstopper that promises to delight every palate.

Imagine tender, custardy bread soaked in a spiced eggnog mixture, baked to golden perfection, and then drizzled with a rich, nutty brown butter sauce. This isn’t just a dessert; it’s an experience, a warm hug in a bowl that embodies the spirit of the festive season. Its comforting aroma will fill your home, inviting everyone to gather and indulge.

*This post contains affiliate links — as an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Please see my disclosure for details*.

And if you enjoy this delightful eggnog brioche bread pudding, you’ll also love my Brown Butter Sweet Potato Pie, my Banana Pudding Cheesecake Squares, or my Christmas Charcuterie Board!

[feast_advanced_jump_to]

Eggnog Bread Pudding: A Decadent Holiday Tradition

If you’re seeking a show-stopping dessert for your holiday spread that combines ease of preparation with unparalleled deliciousness, this eggnog brioche bread pudding is your answer. It’s truly incredible – not only is it one of the best recipes to use up leftover eggnog, but it consistently delivers a rich, comforting flavor profile that epitomizes holiday indulgence. Each bite is a symphony of classic holiday flavors: creamy eggnog, warm vanilla, crunchy pecans, fragrant grated nutmeg, and the delightful kick of rum.

What sets this recipe apart is the choice of bread. Using brioche, with its high butter and egg content, yields an even richer, more tender, and luxurious texture than traditional bread puddings. But the magic doesn’t stop there! The final touch is a generous drizzle of our exquisite brown butter rum sauce, which incorporates even more eggnog, enhancing the existing flavors and adding a layer of nutty, caramelized sweetness. This sauce is truly the crowning glory, making the entire dish absolutely irresistible and perfectly complementing the rich custardy interior of the pudding.

This recipe holds a special place in my heart, dedicated to my dad, the sole eggnog enthusiast in our family! Growing up, a carton of eggnog was a Christmas fridge staple, exclusively for him. Yet, this bread pudding transformed my perspective. While I might not reach for a glass of plain eggnog, I can enjoy this dessert all day long! It showcases how eggnog, when thoughtfully integrated as an ingredient, can create something truly amazing and decadent. It turned me into a believer!

The Rich History Behind “Bread Pudding”

This comforting dessert, known as bread pudding, has a fascinating history rooted in necessity and ingenuity. Its origins trace back to Europe in the 11th and 12th centuries. In England, “pudding” was a traditional term for a rustic, homestyle dessert, often incorporating various ingredients. By the 13th century, many British homes commonly featured a “pudding basin” – a deep bowl in the kitchen specifically used to collect scraps of stale bread. This practice was a practical way to prevent food waste, transforming otherwise discarded bread into a nourishing meal.

Often referred to as “poor man’s pudding” due to its popularity among lower-income families, early bread puddings were remarkably simple. They were typically made by soaking stale bread in water, then sweetening it with sugar and flavoring with readily available spices. Over centuries, as culinary practices evolved, bread pudding transcended its humble beginnings, incorporating richer ingredients like milk, eggs, and butter, eventually developing into the decadent dessert we cherish today, especially this eggnog bread pudding.

Ensuring Perfection: How to Avoid Soggy Bread Pudding

No one wants a soggy bread pudding! With the precise steps in this recipe, your eggnog bread pudding will achieve that perfect balance of moistness and a satisfying, solid texture—never gooey. Here’s how to guarantee a delightful result every time:

1. Embrace Stale Bread: This is arguably the most critical step. Stale bread is porous and has less moisture content, allowing it to absorb the rich custard much more effectively and quickly than fresh bread. To prepare, remove your bread from its packaging, cut it into slices if not already pre-sliced, and separate the slices to expose them to air. Leaving them out overnight allows them to dry sufficiently. If you’re short on time, you can cut the bread into cubes and toast them lightly in the oven at a low temperature (around 300°F / 150°C) for about 15 minutes until dried out.
2. Thicken Your Custard on the Stovetop: Many recipes simply mix cold custard ingredients, but ours takes an extra step that makes a significant difference. By gently heating your custard mixture on the stovetop, you’re not only helping to marry the flavors beautifully but also thickening it slightly. This pre-thickening step ensures that the bread absorbs a richer, more substantial liquid, contributing to a firmer, more satisfying texture in the final baked pudding and preventing it from being too watery.
3. Allow Ample Soaking Time Before Baking: Patience is a virtue, especially in baking! While the anticipation of enjoying your eggnog bread pudding might be high, I strongly recommend allowing the bread to soak in the custard for at least 20-30 minutes after pouring it over. This crucial resting period gives the bread enough time to fully absorb the liquid, ensuring that each cube is thoroughly saturated. This absorption is key to preventing a liquidy or undercooked pudding, resulting in a perfectly set and delicious dessert.

Storage Solutions: Can You Freeze Bread Pudding?

Absolutely! This delightful eggnog bread pudding is surprisingly freezer-friendly, making it an excellent make-ahead option for holiday entertaining or simply to enjoy later. To ensure your bread pudding remains fresh and delicious after freezing, simply follow these key steps:

1. Separate the Sauce: Crucially, do not pour your luscious brown butter rum sauce over your pudding before freezing. The sauce is best prepared fresh or stored separately and added just before serving. Freezing and thawing the sauce directly on the pudding can alter its texture and overall appeal. Keep the sauce in an airtight container for later use.
2. Cool Completely Before Freezing: Allow your freshly baked eggnog bread pudding to cool down entirely to room temperature. Attempting to freeze a warm pudding can lead to condensation and ice crystal formation, which can negatively impact the texture upon thawing. Patience here ensures the best quality.
3. Proper Packaging for Freezer Protection: Once fully cooled, place the bread pudding in a sturdy airtight container. For an extra layer of protection against freezer burn, wrap the container again tightly with plastic wrap or aluminum foil. This double-layer method helps to seal out air and maintain the pudding’s freshness. Properly stored, your eggnog bread pudding can remain fresh in the freezer for up to 2 months. However, for optimal texture and flavor, I always recommend enjoying it as soon as possible – which, given how addictive this dessert is, won’t be a problem at all!

Simplify Your Holidays with Overnight Eggnog Bread Pudding

Planning ahead for holiday meals can be a game-changer, and this overnight eggnog bread pudding option offers incredible convenience without sacrificing flavor or texture. You can prepare the custard and let the bread soak overnight, allowing you to simply bake it off in the morning! In fact, the longer the bread has to soak in the rich custard, the better and more integrated the texture will be, resulting in an even more deeply flavored and uniformly moist pudding.

To prepare it ahead, assemble the bread pudding up to the point of baking (without adding the pecans on top). Cover the baking dish tightly with plastic wrap or foil and place it in the refrigerator for up to one day. When you’re ready to bake, simply retrieve it from the fridge, sprinkle with your chopped pecans, and pop it into the oven. Keep in mind that a chilled pudding may require an additional few minutes of baking time compared to one baked immediately, so adjust accordingly until it’s golden brown and set in the center.

Essential Ingredients for Your Rum Eggnog Bread Pudding

Crafting the perfect rum eggnog bread pudding requires a few key components that contribute to its rich flavor and decadent texture. Here’s a closer look at what you’ll need:

• Brioche Loaf: For the best results, use a stale brioche loaf, cut into 1½-inch cubes. Brioche’s high butter and egg content makes it incredibly rich and tender, ideal for absorbing the custard without becoming mushy. If brioche isn’t available, challah, French bread, or even regular sandwich bread can be used, though they might yield a slightly different texture. Stale bread is crucial for optimal custard absorption.
• Evaporated Milk: This ingredient is a secret weapon in many rich desserts, and it’s fantastic in this bread pudding. With a higher protein content than regular milk, evaporated milk helps the custard thicken beautifully and contributes to a wonderfully creamy, luscious texture.
• Store-Bought Eggnog: The star of the show! You can use your favorite store-bought eggnog or even leftover homemade eggnog. My Oat Milk Eggnog recipe works perfectly here, whether made with oat milk or dairy milk. For the richest flavor and texture, a full-fat version of eggnog is recommended, but low-fat options will also work if that’s what you have on hand.
• Pure Vanilla Extract: Vanilla is a foundational flavor in this bread pudding, adding warmth and depth. Be sure to use a good quality pure vanilla extract for the best aromatic impact.
• Dark Rum: While optional, a splash of dark rum is highly recommended! It beautifully complements the rich, spiced notes of the eggnog, adding a sophisticated warmth and complexity. Any dark or spiced rum will work wonderfully here, enhancing the holiday spirit of the dish.
• Granulated Sugar: Provides the perfect level of sweetness to our rich eggnog custard, balancing the flavors without being overly cloying.
• Salted Butter: I typically use salted butter in my recipes as it helps to balance the sweetness. If you opt for unsalted butter, simply add about ½ teaspoon of salt to your custard ingredients to achieve that balanced flavor profile.
• Eggs: These are essential for creating the signature custardy texture of bread pudding. Along with the milk and eggnog, eggs bind the ingredients together, resulting in a smooth, creamy, and wonderfully set pudding when baked.
• Pecan Halves: Another optional but highly recommended addition! Roughly chopped pecans add a delightful crunch and a rich, nutty flavor that harmonizes perfectly with the buttery notes of the brioche, eggnog, and rum. If you’re a pecan lover like me, you’ll also adore my Butter Pecan Cake with Cream Cheese Frosting!

And then for that amazing brown butter rum sauce, which truly elevates this dessert, you’ll need:

• Salted Butter: The foundation of our brown butter, which develops a rich, nutty flavor when cooked. As with the pudding, if using unsalted butter, a small pinch of salt will enhance the flavor. For more brown butter inspiration, try my Brown Butter Pumpkin Donuts!
• All-Purpose Flour: This acts as a thickening agent for our sauce, creating a smooth, luscious consistency that coats the bread pudding beautifully.
• Dark Brown Sugar: I particularly love dark brown sugar for this sauce because its molasses notes add a deeper, more complex caramelized sweetness that perfectly complements the brown butter and rum.
• Dark Rum: Imparts a delicious, slightly boozy depth to the sauce. If you prefer to omit alcohol, simply replace the rum with 1 teaspoon of pure vanilla extract for a warm, non-alcoholic alternative.
• Eggnog: Adding eggnog directly to the sauce intensifies the overall eggnog flavor profile of the dessert, making it even more cohesive and rich. You can also use whole milk or a milk of your choice if you prefer.
• Freshly Grated Nutmeg: This seemingly small touch makes a huge difference! Freshly grated nutmeg releases a much more potent and aromatic spice, beautifully enhancing the inherent nutmeg flavor found in eggnog and adding an authentic holiday touch. Packaged ground nutmeg can be used as a substitute, but fresh is always superior here.

Now that you’ve gathered all your exquisite ingredients, let’s make sure you have the right tools to bring this incredible eggnog bread pudding to life!

Essential Equipment for Perfect Eggnog Bread Pudding

This recipe is surprisingly straightforward, but having the right tools will make the process even smoother and more enjoyable. Here’s the essential equipment you’ll need:

• Saucepan: You’ll need a reliable saucepan for two key steps: preparing your rich eggnog custard and then for crafting the decadent brown butter rum sauce. A 3-quart saucepan is generally a good size for this recipe.
• Light-Colored Sauté Pan (for brown butter): While a saucepan can work, if your saucepan is dark, I highly recommend using a light-colored or stainless steel sauté pan for browning butter. The light color allows you to clearly observe the milk solids as they toast, ensuring you achieve that perfect nutty brown without burning.
• Baking Dish: You’ll bake everything to golden perfection in either an 8×8 baking pan or a 2-quart casserole dish. These sizes are ideal for the recipe’s yield and ensure even baking.
• Whisk: An essential tool for smoothly combining ingredients for the custard and achieving the right consistency for your brown butter rum sauce. A good whisk prevents lumps and ensures everything is perfectly emulsified.
• Rubber Spatula: Useful for scraping down the sides of bowls, folding ingredients, and ensuring you get every last bit of delicious custard or sauce. A rubber spatula is a versatile kitchen companion.
• Measuring Cups and Spoons: Accurate measurements are key to baking success! Have your standard measuring cups and spoons ready for precise ingredient portions.

Step-by-Step Guide to Crafting Your Eggnog Bread Pudding

Follow these detailed steps to create a truly unforgettable eggnog bread pudding with brown butter rum sauce:

1. Prepare the Bread Base: Begin by greasing an 8×8 baking pan generously with butter or cooking spray. Arrange your chunks of stale brioche (or chosen bread) evenly within the prepared pan. Press them down gently to ensure they fit snugly and fill any gaps, creating a solid base for the pudding.
2. Create the Luscious Custard: In a medium saucepan, combine the eggnog, evaporated milk, beaten eggs, melted butter, and granulated sugar. Place the saucepan over medium heat, whisking the mixture very frequently to prevent scorching and ensure the eggs temper properly. As it warms, the mixture will gradually transform into a velvety custard, thickening slightly. Continue to cook for approximately 10 minutes, maintaining constant vigilance with your whisk. Remove the custard from the heat, then stir in the pure vanilla extract and dark rum (if using).
3. Soak the Bread in Custard: This is a crucial step for a perfectly moist bread pudding. Carefully pour the warm custard evenly over the brioche chunks in the baking dish. Be gentle, as it might splash a bit. Use a wooden spoon or spatula to gently press down on the bread, ensuring that every piece is fully immersed and in contact with the liquid custard. Now, practice patience: allow the bread to soak for at least 30 minutes, or even better, overnight in the refrigerator. This extended soaking time ensures the bread absorbs the custard thoroughly, preventing a dry or watery pudding.
4. Prepare the Brown Butter Rum Sauce: While your eggnog bread pudding is baking, you can prepare the exquisite brown butter rum sauce. In a light-colored saucepan or skillet (the light color helps you monitor the browning process), melt the salted butter over medium heat. Continue cooking, stirring frequently, until the milk solids separate and begin to turn a rich, golden brown, releasing a wonderfully nutty aroma. For more detailed instructions and step-by-step photos on achieving perfect brown butter, consult my Brown Butter Appreciation Post.
5. Thicken the Sauce: Once your butter is perfectly browned, whisk the all-purpose flour into the pan. Continue to cook for another minute or two, whisking continuously, to ensure the flour is fully cooked through and integrated into the brown butter, forming a roux.
6. Infuse the Sauce with Flavor: Stir in the brown sugar and eggnog to the roux, then grate in the fresh nutmeg. Continue cooking and whisking constantly over medium heat until the sauce thickens to your desired consistency – it should be pourable but rich.
7. Add the Rum Finish: Finally, stir in the dark rum (if using) and cook for another minute or two to allow the alcohol to cook off slightly and the flavors to meld. Once the eggnog bread pudding is baked and warm, generously drizzle this incredible brown butter rum sauce over the top. Serve immediately and enjoy!

Expert Tips and Frequently Asked Questions for Eggnog Bread Pudding

More Holiday Recipes You’ll Love

• Mini Basque Cheesecake
• Brownie Mix Cookies with White Chocolate, Cherries and Pistachios

📖 Recipe

PIN this eggnog bread pudding recipe for later!